Saturday, October 4, 2014

Debates: In and Out of Class



Saturday’s class started with a debate of the question:  “If a drug made you smarter, should it be made available?  Two monks came to the front of the room.  Each monk had three minutes to outline their argument and then two more minutes to refute the other monk’s position.  The monk supporting a “smart drug” said that such a drug would benefit everyone because it would increase everyone’s intelligence so people could make better decisions.  The monk against said that the drug would likely be available only to those people who could afford it and would cause a wider divide between people.  I think it was an even match.  The next question to debate next class is:  If you knew that you were going to get a neurological disease such as Alzheimer’s disease in the future, would you want to know now.

After the debate, we discussed the basic size and shape of the brain and differences in brain structure as we develop.  I mentioned how the right side of the brain controls the left side of the body and the left side of the brain controls the right side of the body.  When I was asked why the nervous system was built this way, I said there was no satisfactory answer.  I mentioned some theories, but none fully explained the observation.  We also talked about the corpus callosum and how it connects the hemispheres of the brain.
 
This discussion of brain anatomy lead to brain dominance and laterality.   The monks and nuns knew if they were right or left handed (20 of the 22 monks and nuns were right handed) but few knew of they were right or left footed and none knew if they had a dominant eye or ear.  So we tested this with some simple experiments (e.g., foot used to kick a ball; eye sighting; preference for cupping an ear).  The data showed that right hand dominance was stronger than dominance for the other parts of the body.

We will pick up neuroanatomy with lobes of the brain next time and then start in with neurons and neurotransmission.

No comments:

Post a Comment